I recently joined Vanessa Lana Brown on The Late Late Aesthetics Show to discuss why pigmentation is so difficult to treat, the different types of pigmentation, and what actually works when it comes to skincare and clinical treatments.
Why pigmentation is so often misdiagnosed
Pigmentation is a natural process, it’s the natural colouring of our skin, and we should have pigmentation. Our melanocytes produce melanin, the pigment that gives our skin its colour and the amount of melanin produced is largely determined by our DNA and influenced by things like sun exposure.
Hyperpigmentation occurs when our melanocytes produce an excess amount of melanin compared with our baseline skin tone and the difficulty is that there are so many different things that can trigger this process.
Another issue is that pigmentation can sit at different layers within the skin, it might be in the epidermis, the top layer, or it might be deeper in the dermis, where it’s much more difficult to reach. So we need to make sure we’re treating the right diagnosis and targeting the pigment at the right depth with the right treatment.
There’s also a wider issue when it comes to diagnosing and treating pigmentation in skin of colour. Historically, dermatological research and clinical training have focused heavily on lighter skin tones. There hasn’t always been the same level of understanding of how conditions present and respond to treatment across the full spectrum of skin tones.
I think this is changing, but there’s still work to be done. Treating pigmentation in darker skin isn’t necessarily more difficult, it just requires the right understanding, skill set and approach.
Melasma, dark spots and hyperpigmentation: different causes
In aesthetic practice, the three most common forms of pigmentation I see are post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation, melasma and sunspots, also known as solar lentigines.
Post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation (PIH)
This occurs following inflammation or irritation within the skin, such as acne. It’s particularly common in darker skin tones because melanocytes can be more reactive to inflammation and irritation, making the skin more prone to developing dark marks.
When treating PIH, we want to reduce the inflammation, increase skin cell turnover in a way that respects the skin barrier, and suppress the overproduction of melanin.
Melasma
Melasma is a little more complex, we don’t know exactly why some people develop it and others don’t, but we do know that there’s often an interplay between hormonal and environmental factors. There may be an underlying hormonal trigger, such as pregnancy, certain contraceptive pills or hormone replacement therapy.
When that hormonal influence interacts with UV exposure and heat, it can contribute to the development of melasma - some people may also be genetically predisposed.
Melasma is particularly challenging because it’s a chronic, relapsing condition. We may be able to put it into remission, but there’s always the possibility that it can return.
Sunspots
Sunspots are associated with cumulative sun exposure and our melanocytes are stimulated by UV radiation to produce melanin. During the summer, when UV exposure increases, those cells receive more stimulation.
Over time, repeated unprotected sun exposure can contribute to damage that presents as sunspots later in life. This is why we sometimes see pigmentation appearing decades after the original sun exposure.
Why SPF matters all year round
There’s a reason why doctors are always talking about sunscreen, it’s one of the best things you can do to protect your skin. We know that UV radiation contributes to skin cancer risk, but it also affects pigmentation, collagen degradation, hyaluronic acid degradation and premature skin ageing.
You can use retinoids, peptides, lasers and all sorts of other treatments, but if you’re not protecting your skin from UV exposure, you’re undermining the work you’re doing.
And sunscreen isn’t just important during summer. If you care about pigmentation, fine lines, wrinkles and overall skin quality, SPF is still important during winter because UVA radiation is present all year.
How much sunscreen should you apply?
For the face, I generally recommend as is industry standard two full finger lengths of sunscreen, with reapplication approximately every two hours when you’re exposed to daylight.
I appreciate that reapplying can be difficult, particularly if you’re wearing makeup, sunscreen sprays and facial mists can make reapplication more convenient, although it’s still important to apply enough product to achieve adequate coverage.
The skincare ingredients that actually work
When it comes to treating hyperpigmentation, there are multiple steps involved in the development of excess pigment. So we need to target several of those steps rather than relying on one ingredient.
First, we need sunscreen. UV radiation stimulates melanocytes to produce more melanin, so protecting the skin is the foundation.
Next, we need antioxidants. One of the most common antioxidants used in skincare is vitamin C, I like to describe antioxidants as helping to mop up some of the environmental triggers that sunscreen can’t catch.
Then we want to increase skin cell turnover. This is where retinoids and exfoliating ingredients come into play, but it’s important that we’re not being too harsh, because excessive irritation can trigger further pigmentation.
Finally, we need to target the overproduction of melanin itself.
This is where tyrosinase inhibitors come in. Ingredients such as arbutin, kojic acid and hydroquinone can help target melanin production, although stronger treatments such as hydroquinone require appropriate professional guidance. The important thing is that we’re targeting the different pathways involved in pigmentation and skincare really is the foundation.
Everyone wants to jump straight into clinical treatments, but what you’re doing for your skin every single day is incredibly important too.
How long does it take to see results?
I generally tell my patients to give me six to nine months, that means six to nine months of consistent skincare and, where appropriate, a course of treatments.
Of course, it depends on the type of pigmentation and the individual’s skin type. Some sunspots may respond relatively quickly to certain treatments, whereas post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation and melasma in darker skin tones may require a longer, more consistent approach.
And if I had to choose one skincare ingredient for pigmentation, assuming you’re already wearing sunscreen, I’d probably choose a good-quality retinoid. That’s because retinoids help stimulate skin cell turnover and can also have an effect on the pathways involved in melanin production.
The mistakes that make it worse
One of the biggest mistakes people make is spending money on the wrong skincare. I see people trying lots of viral products, using multiple over-the-counter serums or following ten-step routines that aren’t actually targeting their pigmentation.
Sometimes they’re simply layering hydration without addressing the underlying concern. And there’s no point investing in clinical treatments if you’re not supporting those treatments with an appropriate skincare routine at home.
Another mistake is being too aggressive with your skin. If you’re using too many active ingredients, over-exfoliating or repeatedly irritating your skin, you can create more inflammation. And in skin that’s prone to post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation, that can make the problem worse.
I also see people stopping all their active skincare during summer. You don’t necessarily need to stop your retinoids, exfoliants or vitamin C simply because the weather is warmer.
You may need to adjust how frequently you use them or when you apply them, depending on your skin and sun exposure, but stopping everything isn’t always the best approach.
The other major mistake is not being careful enough with sun exposure. Not wearing enough sunscreen, failing to reapply it, sitting in direct sunlight for prolonged periods and allowing the skin to overheat can all contribute to pigmentation concerns.
Finally, I think we need to move away from the idea that there’s one miracle product that will fade pigmentation quickly. There isn’t, pigmentation management is a combination approach that takes time and should be in experienced hands.
My final thoughts
One of the last things I said during the episode is something I really want people to remember is that no one sees your skin concerns as severely as you do. I know pigmentation can have a significant psychological impact and it can affect people’s confidence and quality of life, and I don’t want to take away from that, but we’re often our own harshest critics.
We look at ourselves in mirrors, selfies and Zoom calls, focusing on details that other people may barely notice. I see patients who feel their pigmentation is incredibly severe, and sometimes I wish I could help them see themselves the way other people do.
So yes, understanding your pigmentation and treating it appropriately matters, but so does remembering that your skin concerns don’t define you.
Keep reading